The Common Council voted to advance Option 4, a proposed $107.2 million project to construct an all-new library and city hall building. Option 4 would replace the existing aging infrastructure built in 1957 with a modern, energy-efficient facility designed to serve the community for decades.

Breakdown of the Taxpayer Impact & Funding Plan

The Common Council heard from residents that they wanted the features of Option 4, but were concerned about the cost. So, they voted to cap the taxpayer-funded portion of the project at $67.8 million. For an average home assessed at $418,800, this equals $20/month over 20 years. (Remember that commercial properties will also contribute to funding this total based on their assessed property values.)

How the Remaining Cost Will Be Covered

Because lowering the direct taxpayer cap leaves a gap in the $107.2 million budget, the city will pursue a hybrid funding strategy:

• Grant funding: Applying for federal, state, and sustainability grants focused on clean energy and public infrastructure.
• Private fundraising: Launching targeted fundraising campaigns and seeking private contributions.
• If there is a gap in the amount after that work is completed, the Common Council will further discuss the project. That discussion could include scope changes, increasing the city contribution, designing a different project, or more.

Features of Option 4

• A new children's library (relocated to 1st floor): Moved to the ground level for easier access, featuring enhanced interactive activity areas, a larger dedicated program room, and a secure outdoor play space.
• Adds a dedicated Teen Zone, a specialized Local History Room, a high-tech Makerspace, and significantly more community meeting rooms and quiet study spaces.
• Features a new drive-up book return and 24/7 accessible book lockers located near the exterior drop-off.
• Net-zero energy. Designed so 100% of the facility's annual energy needs are offset by renewable energy sources, protecting taxpayers from future energy costs.

Project Timeline and Next Steps

Because Option 4 involves razing the existing facility, the entire site layout remains flexible - and public feedback will directly inform the design. The Council asked for quarterly public updates throughout the process, beginning with an initial site plan update this November. Stay tuned for future meeting dates and opportunities to share your input. (The renderings shared represent concepts and not the final designs.)

Concurrently, the Wauwatosa Public Library will launch its private fundraising campaign.

Depending on the progress of fundraising and grants, construction could begin as early as 2028.

What Happens During Construction?

Because Option 4 requires the total demolition of the current site, city hall and library services will be displaced during construction.

City staff are actively exploring temporary leases nearby to host offices and core library services throughout the build phase. While essential city services will remain accessible, residents should anticipate reduced physical space and modified service offerings during the transition period.